06/23/2026
https://www.facebook.com/share/1DHPywAhg6/?mibextid=wwXIfr
He was a Pennsylvania Dutch boy.
He stood for a photograph with 3rd Platoon, number 28 in the lineup.
Then he asked to do something even harder than what Easy Company was already doing.
He volunteered for the Pathfinders. ๐๏ธ
His name was Carl L. Fenstermaker.
Born February 1, 1923, in Pennsylvania, likely in the same Pennsylvania Dutch country of Lehigh County and the surrounding region that produced Forrest Guth, with whom he shared a fluency in the Pennsylvania Dutch dialect, the language of German settlers carried forward through two centuries of inheritance in the inland counties of eastern Pennsylvania.
He was one of three close friends, Forrest Guth, Carl Fenstermaker, and Roderick Strohl, who spoke that dialect together in the barracks, three Pennsylvania Dutch boys who had found each other in the middle of a war and held onto the language their families had carried across an ocean.
He was officially recognised, in a United States Senate resolution honouring Easy Company decades later, as one of twelve native Pennsylvanians among the original 140 men who built the company at Camp Toccoa, Georgia, listed alongside Dick Winters, Thomas Meehan, Harry Welsh, Jack Foley, Joe Toye, Bill Guarnere, Forrest Guth, Babe Heffron, and Albert Blithe.
He was assigned to Easy Company, 2nd Battalion, 506th Parachute Infantry Regiment, 101st Airborne Division, with the rank of Private First Class.
A surviving 1943 photograph taken during the company's legendary 120-mile march from Toccoa to Atlanta, Georgia, captures him on a rest break with the rest of 3rd Platoon. He is identified by name as number 28 in the lineup, standing among men whose names history would later make famous: Mike Ranney, Shifty Powers, Paul Rogers, Buck Taylor, Ed Tipper, Carwood Lipton, Forrest Guth, Frank Perconte, Floyd Talbert, Walter Gordon, Kenneth Baldwin, and Lavon Reese.
He ran Currahee.
He completed the full 120-mile march alongside the rest of his Toccoa brothers.
At some point in his service, Carl Fenstermaker volunteered for the Pathfinders, the specialised airborne troops who dropped first, ahead of the main body of paratroopers, to set up the navigational beacons and marking systems that guided the larger formations down to the correct ground. It was among the most exposed and dangerous roles in the entire airborne structure, the first men on the ground, alone, with no strength of numbers to fall back on until the rest of the formation arrived.
His acceptance into the Pathfinders required his transfer out of Easy Company.
He left the friends he had trained with from the beginning, Guth and Strohl, the men he had spoken his grandparents' language with in the barracks, and went to serve in a role that asked even more of him than Toccoa already had.
The verified record on Carl Fenstermaker's specific combat actions, post-war life, and family details beyond this is thin. What is confirmed is his Pennsylvania Dutch heritage, his close friendship with Forrest Guth and Roderick Strohl, his place in the 3rd Platoon photograph from the Toccoa-to-Atlanta march, his official recognition by the United States Senate as one of Easy Company's twelve native Pennsylvanians, and his volunteer transfer to the Pathfinders.
Carl L. Fenstermaker died on June 30, 1988.
He was 65 years old.
He spoke Pennsylvania Dutch with his closest friends in a Georgia barracks.
He marched 120 miles from Toccoa to Atlanta and stood for a photograph afterward, one face among the men the world would come to call legends.
He was one of twelve Pennsylvania boys who built Easy Company from nothing.
He looked at what Easy Company was already being asked to do and volunteered to do something even more dangerous, going first into the dark so the rest could find their way down safely.
Carl Fenstermaker.
A Pennsylvania Dutch boy.
A Pathfinder.
One of the twelve. ๐๏ธ๐บ๐ธ๐ฆ
โ ๏ธโ ๏ธ
This true story is based on historical records and shared for educational purposes only.