05/20/2026
Then and Now: 214 West Main Street
This unassuming building has been part of Mount Joy’s story for nearly two centuries.
Originally known as the Old Bethel Church, the building was dedicated on December 25, 1838, making it the oldest church building in Mount Joy. It served the community until 1852, when it was sold for $330 to the Church of God. Worship continued here for decades, and in 1874 it became the New Mennonite Church, remaining active until the congregation dissolved in August 1935.
Not long after, the building began a new chapter. Harry and Mary Landvater bought the former church, renovated it into their family home, and opened Landvater’s Grocery Store in the same space by the end of the year, blending business and family with a space that was once reserved for worship.
In 1950, the Landvater’s sold the store to Saumel W. Heisey and it became Heisey’s Food Store. After 8 years in business Heisey’s closed up shop and the building became the home of Longenecker’s Meat Market, continuing to serve the community. The store continued on under a variety of names and owners until 1969.
Today, the building houses apartments, but still retains the bones of the original 1838 structure, a quiet reminder of faith, family, and business in Mount Joy.
Love uncovering local history? Join the Mount Joy Area Historical Society and help us preserve local history. Don’t forget to like and comment!
