09/02/2026
THE MYSTERY OF THE CROY – SKINNER – LONGTRENTH CEMETERY
By Kay Wilson, Historical So. Genealogist and Military expert 740-385-6204 Aug. 31, 2026
Doing Cemetery research is often very easy, other times it is so confusing. Skinner cemetery, in Starr Township is very complex.
As many of you know, I am trying to organize all the old cemetery records for Hocking County. Our goal is to put them all on a database for easy reference for all. There are several lists of cemeteries; and different names on them. One example is the Croy – Skinner, Skinner-Croy, Skinner -Longstreth Cemetery, and some lists list them each as separate cemeteries.
Also, if you know of any forgotten family cemeteries, I am very interested in adding them to the information.
(On the internet “People Legacy” has it listed as Skinner Croy Cemetery and states it has 22 burials. Also, it is also known as Croy Cemetery. The Latitudes: 39.466699, Longitude: - 82.25622.
The earlies burial was in 1844 for Catherine Mitchell, and an Infant Son Cole less than 2 months old. The last burials were for Allie McDivitt and Margery Duffy in 1869.
Yet another list has Croy Cemetery ½ miles north of Union Furnace. And Skinner Cemetery 1/8 mile north of Union Furnace, that would put the Croy Cemetery approximately on the top of the “Old Presbyterian Church Farm hill.”)
On “CoPilot Search” online it has it listed as the Skinner Cemetery, Croy Cemetery, and the Longstreth Cemetery, is located in Starr Township, and situated in Section 25 of Starr Township, about “1/2” mile north of Union Furnace on the east side of St. Rt. 328. The coordinates match the ones listed above.)
In the 2012 Hocking County Road Atlas, the cemetery is only known as Skinner Cemetery in section 24 Starr Township. Enclosed you will find a copy of the 1873 Starr township map of section 24. The one for Skinners is in the correct area.
Jim Skinner agreed with Louise Duffy, after his father (C.W. Skinner) bought the farm from about 1948 - 1950, it was called the Skinner Cemetery. It had previously been called Longstreth Cemetery. J.D. Longstreth family were the earlier landowners.
Both Jim and Louise remembered there had been many additional graves coming toward the road of St. Rt. 328. At one time sheep had pastured in the area, so many stones were down and gone.
The following list of burials found in that cemetery, it was done on April 9, 1971, by Bob Redd.
NAMES DIED AGE
Bennet, Betsy 1839
Botts, James P.A. 10 Sept. 1847 12 yr, 6 mo. 11 da
Botts, John 9 Sept. 1847 12 yr, 6 mo. 10 da
Cole, Infant Son 12 Apr. 1844 1 mo. 2 da
Croy, Mattias 5 July, 1843 4 yr, 3 mo.
Duffy, Daniel 29, Apr. 1869 67, 2 mo. 9 da
Fox Asa 13 Aug. 1964 43 yrs
Harper, Calvary M. 14 Sept. 1848 21 yr, 10 mo. 11 da
Harper, Loiza 12, Sept. 1848 21 yr 20 mo. 9 da
Ingmire, Margaret 22 Apr. 1849 83 yr
Ingmire, Martha 30 Aug, 1848 51 yr
Ingmire, Thomas 10 July, 1960 63 yr
Kriebel, Jaccob 21 Sept. 1868 1 yr, 7 mo.
Loomis, Jesse H. Rev. 1859
Lottridge, John W. 21 May, 1846 8 mo.
Matheny, Martha 12 Apr. 1849 91 yr, 11 mo. 27 da
McDivitt, Allie 26 Aug. 1869 2 mo. 15 da
Mitchell, Catherine 10 Sept. 1844 21 yr, 5 mo. 26 da
Mitchell, Joanna 28 Oct. 1844 1 yr, 9 mo. 1 da
Purdum, Emma 11 Apr. 1860 3 mo. 11 da
ANOTHER FOUND LIST HAD 2 ADDITIONAL NAMES
Bennet, Jacob 1861
Pedrum, Mary 1850
1876 Hocking County Atlas