10/03/2024
“To the Great Joy of the Whole Province”
On this day in 1718, Colonel William Rhett, vice-admiral of the Colonial Navy, sailed into Charleston harbor carrying more than three dozen pirate prisoners captured in the defeat of “gentleman pirate” Major Stede Bonnet at the Cape Fear River.
Rhett, a wealthy planter, served as a member of the South Carolina General Assembly as well as its colonial militia. He commanded an improvised flotilla defending against an attack on Charleston by Jacques Lefebvre and Estevan de Berroa during Queen Anne’s War in 1709, ultimately capturing the ship Brilliant and taking nearly 100 prisoners.
An active merchant captain, Rhett had a bone to pick with pirates. In 1699, on a business trip between Charleston and St. Thomas, his ship Providence was attacked and taken by Dutch pirate Hendrick van Hoven (also known as Captain Hyne).
In 1718, following attacks on the town by both Blackbeard and Charles Vane, Rhett provided two sloops - the Sea Nymph and the Henry - to defend against and root out sea rovers lurking in nearby coastal waters. Each was armed with 8 guns and crewed by 60 and 70 men respectively.
It was this pair of pirate-hunting vessels that Rhett led to victory (though only after grounding both and taking heavy casualties) over Bonnet’s Royal James (renamed from Revenge after briefly taking a pardon) and its crew.
Tending to their wounded and making repairs after the short but brutal battle, Rhett and his men remained at the site for two days before weighing anchor on September 30th. According to a contemporary account (The Tryals of Stede Bonnet & Other Pirates - 1719), they “arrived at Charles Town the 3d of October to the great joy of the whole province”.
There being no public prison at Charleston, the majority of the pirates were confined in the watch house under heavy guard of the local militia. Stede Bonnet (who had been operating under the name Captain Thomas since his pardon), along with the ship’s master and boatswain, were kept in the private home of the town’s Marshal, with only two men on watch at night.
With the help of local scoundrel Richard Tookerman, Bonnet and the master David Herriot escaped custody on October 24th.
We shall continue the tale on the aforementioned date.