Cortland County Historical Society

Cortland County Historical Society Telling Your Stories Since 1925! Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok for local history! We love to share life in the past lane with you!

The Cortland County Historical Society was founded in 1925 and we have been serving up local history ever since. We offer programs about local history, house an excellent research center (as well as a museum full of super cool artifacts!), have educational kits available for organizations to borrow, and we table at several festivals within the county each year. CCHS is home to both the Suggett Hou

se Museum and the Kellogg Memorial Research Center. The Suggett House is a wonderful museum with artifacts that span the two centuries of Cortland County history, though our collection includes items from four centuries (mid 1700s-today). We have fabulous items like Major General Samuel G. Hatheway’s hat and epaulets, a rocking horse owned by Dr. H.O. Jewett, Francis Bicknell Carpenter paintings, a very rare bloomer costume, furniture from the homes of both Jedediah Barber and William Randall, wreaths and jewelry made from human hair, and so very much more! If you don’t know who these folks are or why they are important, be sure to stop by to hear their stories. The Suggett House Museum is also home to our recent addition, the Then & Now Children's Room, a child sized history room where kids can explore history with hands on activities and play. Our research center is a treasure trove of information about our shared past. We have diaries, letters, photographs, family files and genealogies, vital statistics, census records, cemetery records, and town, church and school records. This list barely scratches the surface of what is stored within the library and vault at CCHS! We are here to provide assisted research or you can hire us to do research for you if you are unable to visit us. We are open Wednesday through Saturday from 12-5pm. Please call ahead to confirm we will be open as we occasionally take the show on the road for local festivals which means staff will not be available on site. Our number is 607-756-6071. We look forward to assisting you with your research needs or showing you through our quaint museum.

HistoryForge: Stories from the 1910 Census – Post 1Today we are starting a new series of posts that will highlight our o...
06/22/2026

HistoryForge: Stories from the 1910 Census – Post 1

Today we are starting a new series of posts that will highlight our ongoing online project: HistoryForge. We’ll call this series “Stories From the 1910 Census” and it will be about some of the interesting people and places we’ve come across while transcribing the data from the 1910 census into the HistoryForge site.

HistoryForge combines historic maps and photos with census records of the people who lived in the city and county of Cortland, New York, creating a unique way to visualize the history of the community in the early 1900’s. At this point in time, the entire 1910 census has been transcribed to the site, and the 1920 census is in progress. We are also slowly adding photos, news items and other records pertinent to the places mapped on the site, making it an even more robust view of the community’s past. But beyond the data, beyond the information that can be gleaned from the website, HistoryForge is also a useful tool to help us acknowledge and reflect on “CHANGE”. Change is one of the few constants that affect every community, large or small, diverse or not. Change can be positive or negative, usually both at different points in time and how people feel about change over the long term will depend on how people react or respond to it along the way.

So, if we want to examine how change has happened in the Cortland community over time, a great place to start is with the 1910 census, a census taken in the middle of a rapidly changing United States. The few years before and after 1910 were a pivotal time in U.S. history, kicking off a transformative decade that included progressive social and governmental reforms, a transportation revolution in the form of the automobile and rapid industrialization throughout the country. In every area of their lives, socially, politically, economically, Americans were being significantly affected by the rapid pace of change. And the 1910 census was already recording some of the changes happening, even in smaller cities, like Cortland, away from the large populations in the big cities. For instance, people were on the move. People in this country were moving from the south to the north looking for a better life. And more important for Cortland, people were moving from European countries to the U.S. According to Ancestry.com, more than 15 million immigrants came to this country in the years between 1900 and 1915, with immigration peaking at 1.2 million arrivals in 1907 alone. Most of these people came from Eastern, Central, and Southern Europe. Many were Italians, heading to big cities with neighborhoods full of compatriots. But many also traveled further afield, looking for jobs and opportunities, to places like Cortland.

In 1892, the state census recorded four Italians living in Cortland. Thirteen years later in 1905, there were nearly two hundred. But by 1910, just five years later, that number had more than doubled to four hundred and ninety-six. The St. Anthony’s Day Parade began in Cortland in 1905 and by 1910 was already a tradition with one hundred adults and forty children participating. Many of the Italians showing up on the 1910 census were men who had recently arrived in the country and were boarding in overpacked houses in Wards 5 and 6. Many were single, though some were married with wives and family back in Italy. Some intended to earn money and go back to Italy and others hoped to bring their families here. The majority worked in the factories, springing up like mushrooms, across those two wards.

On the census, too, were those Italians who had already been in the city for a few years. They had their family already here and some of their children were Americans, born in this country, or even right here in Cortland. Though some were struggling still in this new life, many were already well on their way to their own “American Dream”. The 1910 census can’t quite capture those distinctions, but future census records and more will show that these Italian men and women and their children become sponsors, mentors and leaders within the Italian community and Cortland as a whole. Through activities involving church, social clubs, music, and sports and by becoming teachers and business leaders, they wove strong threads into the fabric of Cortland until this day.

In our next post, we will look more closely at one such Italian family in the 1910 census: the Fabrizios.

~ Taryn, CCHS Volunteer and HistoryForge Transcriber

Photo of the week!Homer Academy's graduating class of 1912 pose on the Homer Green with the Elizabeth Brewster House vis...
06/18/2026

Photo of the week!

Homer Academy's graduating class of 1912 pose on the Homer Green with the Elizabeth Brewster House visible in the background.
The individuals are unidentified, but would likely include Jessie Fisher Bean, Bessie Arla Carpenter, Sylvenus W. Churchill, Florence S. Cobb, Orris John Crosley, Ralph Charles Crosley, Donald Crofoot Foster, Clara Margaret Gates, Edna Alice Gillette, Rose Anna Hagen, Maguerite Edna Judge, Lawrence Carpenter Knapp, Edward Leslie Knapp, Mary Whyte Knobel, Marion H. Manchester, Sarah C. Manchester, Laura Frances Martin, Ward Tisdale Merrick, Genevieve Irene Phelps, Carleton Edwin Rice, Florence May Rice, Nina Maryon Springer, Ruth Starr, Pearl L. Warn, and Ida J.A. Woodmansee.

Join us tomorrow night for this informative talk! Details here: https://www.facebook.com/share/194dqcXnxt/This presentat...
06/16/2026

Join us tomorrow night for this informative talk! Details here: https://www.facebook.com/share/194dqcXnxt/

This presentation will provide the Haudenosaunee perspective on the American Revolution -- the nature of the Haudenosaunee Alliance, history of treaty making, impact of the Clinton-Sullivan Campaign on the Haudenosaunee peoples, the illegal taking of land through the Military Tract, the relationship of wampum to the United States Constitution, and challenges to maintain sovereignty.

Jake Haiwhagai’i Edwards, Onondaga Eel Clan, lives on the Onondaga Nation Territory and maintains the continuity of the Longhouse oral teachings. Jake was appointed by the Grand Council of the Haudenosaunee Confederacy to the Haudenosaunee External Relations Committee to respectfully work on political and governmental structures beyond the borders of Haudenosaunee Country. This work includes diplomatic work at the United Nations and other entities outside the Confederacy. Jake was one of the primary voices leading the 400th anniversary (1613 – 2013) of the Two Row Wampum Campaign. He is a board member of the Seventh Generation Fund for Indigenous Peoples and a board member of the Indigenous Values Initiative.

06/15/2026

Join Collections & Research Assistant, Sophie Welburn, as she makes a book box for one of the ledgers from our archival collections!
A book box is a great way to protect fragile books and ledgers, especially by preventing scraping on the covers, or by stabilizing them when standing upright on the shelf.
Book by book, Sophie has been working to make these enclosures to ensure these one-of-a-kind records are available for researchers for many years to come!
Consider becoming a member of CCHS, or donating to help us purchase materials, and become a part of preserving Cortland's history!

Buffalo Bill Cody died in 1917, but this larger than life entertainer is still remembered today for his Wild West Show t...
06/12/2026

Buffalo Bill Cody died in 1917, but this larger than life entertainer is still remembered today for his Wild West Show that presented an exaggerated view of life in the American West. Did you know that Buffalo Bill brought his show to Cortland four times?

William F. Cody was born in Iowa in 1846 and went out on his own at the age of eleven. He worked as a cattle herder, a driver on a wagon train, a fur trapper, and he even tried his hand at gold mining. He became a scout for the U.S. Army, which is where he gained his nickname Buffalo Bill. Cody’s path intertwined with dime novelist Ned Buntline, and with that, his entire trajectory changed.

Cody’s foray into show business began with a stage show in 1872, but over time, it became a traveling show with performers and animals. Buffalo Bill traveled all over the world, bringing an aggrandized version of life in the American West with him. Among the acts portrayed regularly was a stagecoach attacked by Native Americans which was then rescued by cowboys. In another act, a sleeping scout was attacked by Native Americans and rescued by Buffalo Bill himself. After an appearance at the Cortland County Fairgrounds, the Cortland Standard of September 18, 1884 stated, “In fact the whole exhibition was well worth attendance and was an exact counterpart of what occurs in the great West.”

Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show would firmly establish the stereotypes of the American West that would persist for years, but in his private life, he sympathized with the tribes who he believed should be able to defend their families and their lands from the encroaching United States. By the end of his life, Cody had become an advocate for Native American civil rights and actively used his connections to set up meetings between tribal representatives and politicians.

The Buffalo Bill Museum has a detailed list of performances, and the dates Cody visited Cortland were September 15-16, 1884; September 16, 1895; June 14, 1901; and June 24, 1911. ~Tabitha Scoville, CCHS Director

Buffalo Bill Cody, full-length portrait, seated, facing left, holding rifle. , 1903. Photograph. https://www.loc.gov/item/94512281/.

Photo of the week!The Owego Street School under construction.  The contract of erecting the building was awarded to Ford...
06/11/2026

Photo of the week!

The Owego Street School under construction. The contract of erecting the building was awarded to Ford and Van Ness of Owego, N.Y., and conducted from May-November of 1915.

Did you attend any of the legendary concerts at SUNY Cortland--you know, back when Jackson Browne, Billy Joel, Simon & G...
06/04/2026

Did you attend any of the legendary concerts at SUNY Cortland--you know, back when Jackson Browne, Billy Joel, Simon & Garfunkel--and SO many more--played? You're not going to want to miss a night to reminisce about all the fabulous shows you saw! The SUNY Cortland Musical Legacy Committee is hosting a reception Friday, June 5 from 5-8pm at the Corey Union, and you're invited! See you there 😁

Photo of the week!Postcard image of horses from Augustus K. Bennett's livery in Cincinnatus, circa 1900. Mr.Bennett of T...
06/04/2026

Photo of the week!

Postcard image of horses from Augustus K. Bennett's livery in Cincinnatus, circa 1900. Mr.Bennett of Taylor purchased the Cincinnatus hotel in 1899, at which time he also started up the livery business.

Address

25 Homer Avenue
Cortland, NY
13045

Opening Hours

Wednesday 12pm - 5pm
Thursday 12pm - 5pm
Friday 12pm - 5pm
Saturday 12pm - 5pm

Telephone

+16077566071

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cortland County Historical Society posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Museum

Send a message to Cortland County Historical Society:

Share

Category