09/17/2026
“This is an extremely rare Dutch fowler of the very plain trade quality and one of the few to ever surface in upstate New York.
It has a slender part-octagon barrel 53½ inches long and of .65 caliber. The lock is of early form with sharp bevels at the tail and thin attached pan. It can be seen in the enlarged view that the sear spring was filed with a projecting rectangular stud at the top front end and this stud is driven through a slot in the lock plate to hold the spring in place.
The hammer or c**k has an unusual sharp curve at the neck but this is typical of several found at the old Iroquois village of Gannogaro (now Boughton Hill) destroyed by the French in 1687. The light iron trigger guard is similar to several iron guards found at Gannogaro and at the Susquehannock village site ca. 1625-1675 known as the Strickler Site in Pennsylvania. Hamilton was not aware of these iron guards found archaeologically when he illustrated and briefly described this gun in Colonial Frontier Guns (Chadron, NE. 1980), page 28.
There is, of course, no way of positively identifying this gun as Dutch but all the diagnostic features make it appear to be Dutch of the period before English domination of New York. The gun was purchased locally some 50 years ago and was evidently a family heirloom preserved for its association with early wars or with other activities of some ancestor. It is a perfect example of the light mid-17th century trade guns sold to Iroquoian tribes. It has surprisingly good balance and would obviously handle well for off-hand shooting.
This is the kind of gun the Iroquois learned to use and depend upon and it is the kind spoken of by the people of New Netherlands in their ‘Remonstrance’ to the Lord States General of the United Netherlands in 1649 describing the Indians of New York: ‘Their weapons used to be a war club and the bow and arrow, which they know how to use with wonderful skill. Now, those residing near, or trading considerably with the Christians, make use of firelocks and hatchets, which they obtain in barter. They are excessively fond of guns; spare no expense on them, and are so expert with them that, in this respect, they excel many Christians.’”
~The Museum of the Fur Trade Quarterly, vol. 20, no. 1, (Spring, 1984), Collection Corner: “1650 Dutch Trade Gun from New York.”