02/06/2026
One of Chicago’s most beautiful theaters was lost after a public fight that helped awaken preservation in the city. The Garrick Theater opened in 1892 as part of the Schiller Building, designed by Louis Sullivan and Dankmar Adler. It stood on Randolph Street with offices above and a lavish auditorium inside.
Then, crowds came for opera, plays, movies, and later television work. The most famous detail of its life was Sullivan’s rich ornament, especially the deeply patterned arches and ceiling around the stage. Flowers, star-like forms, and flowing plaster designs made the theater feel alive, as if stone and plaster were growing.
Then, many people believed old buildings could be replaced without regret. By 1961, the theater was demolished, despite protests and a court fight.
Photographer Richard Nickel worked to record it and save pieces of its decoration before the wreckers finished their job. A parking garage replaced the masterpiece.
Now, the Garrick itself is gone, but fragments survive in collections and memories. What was once a shining Chicago theater has now become a powerful symbol of lost architecture and a turning point in the city’s historic preservation story for architects, students, and visitors who study its ruins carefully today.