05/18/2026
At the busy intersection of Dufferin and Steeles, spanning the Toronto and Vaughan borders, there was once the small rural community of Fisherville.
Named, unsurprisingly, after the Pennsylvanian German Fisher family who settled in the area in 1797, there are very few reminders or surviving pieces of heritage near the hub of the old community but bits of Fisherville have been preserved - if you know where to look.
There is a street nearby named Fisherville Road and a TDSB school, Fisherville Senior Public School, that help keep the name relevant. And if you can manage to catch a glance north while speeding along Steeles, just east of Dufferin, you might see a battered old blue plaque that was erected in 1975 communicating that this was Fisherville.
Tucked in behind that, on the rise of a hill and heading back into the valley that leads to a branch of the West Don River, are the remains of the Fisherville United Church, previously the Fisherville Presbyterian Church, cemetery. In 1967 the surviving stones were gathered into an interesting shaped cairn and have been somewhat preserved. Behind that, heading into the brush that made me feel like I was back in Scarborough at the expansive rear section of my grandparent's property overlooking Highland Creek, there are the remains of at least 7 headstone bases which may be a more accurate indication of where some of these early settlers are buried. The cemetery is easily accessible as a pedestrian but although there are sidewalks the area is not exactly friendly for walkers; this is the domain of fast moving vehicles and we heard more than one expletive hurled out a car window.
Despite this being the only in-situ remainder of Fisherville, none of the actual Fisher family are buried here. Jacob Fisher's granddaughter Elizabeth, for example, married fellow Pennsylvanian German settler Daniel Stong and they built the buildings and farmed the land that Black Creek Pioneer Village (now The Village at Black Creek) was established around. A little bit to the west of Fisherville, at Steeles and Jane, the property became Elizabeth’s after the early deaths of her father John Fisher, who died before he could even clear the lot, and then her only brother who died during the War of 1812. Thus, in a way, BCPV actually owes its roots to the Fishers as well. Elizabeth and her husband are buried in the Kaiserville Townline Cemetery which, like their grain barn, first home and second home, is original to the site.
The Fisherville Presbyterian Church was started in 1832 by David Smellie and John Brock/Brack/Brach. The cemetery may have been in use as early as that date but the oldest surviving headstone dates from 1840, 17-year old Isabella, wife of William Watson. In 1856 the congregation built the church that still stands, albeit a little west. The stucco-covered wood framed building was saved from development in the area and moved to Black Creek Pioneer Village in 1960. It stands beside the cemetery mentioned above, in the original location of the Kaiserville Townline Church. The church is open for regular visitors to the site and is often used for modern weddings. Across the way is the Manse, built for yet another church but set-up in the village as if it were this church’s manse. I worked at BCPV for a few seasons, this was one of my favourite buildings to work in and when it was quiet, which it often was at this lonely end of the village, I would wander over to the church and cemetery. The Townline cemetery is visible and has, in the past, sometimes been accessible, but most often is simply viewed from the fence in the Village. (You can also catch glimpses of both the church and the cemetery if you quickly look south-east when forced by all the fast moving transport trucks to blast through the busy intersection of Jane and Steeles.)
What of church founders David Smellie and John Brack? Despite an inaccurate 1933 newspaper article stating that they were both buried in the church cemetery, David Smellie and his family actually rest at Mount Pleasant Cemetery in Toronto. The Smellie property was later used to house the Langstaff Industrial Jail Farm, which was developed to get prisoners, including women, away from places like the overcrowded Don Jail and working out in fresh air. As for John Brack, it seems he and several family members were all buried here but at some point, presumably after 1933, were all moved to Maple Cemetery. It is unknown if all the remains were moved or just the markers. One of the family monuments that contains many names, appears to have been completed for or after the move to Maple and I surmise it was engraved to include everyone who did not have a stone at Fisherville.
The names that do appear on markers that have been cut and fit into the stone and concrete cairn include Coleman, Conacher, Dunoon, Halls, Hord, Long, Maxwell, McCrackin, Smith, Troyer, Watson and Young.
Of these, Troyer is the name that may be familiar to anyone who grew up or passed by the Fisherville area, where North York met the Township of Vaughan, because the octagonal barn that was built for Samuel Troyer in the 1880s stood as a landmark in the area until late 1977. At that time it was dismantled, and despite some inaccurate reports that it was demolished, it too was moved west. But waaayyy further west than the Fisherville Church! The Troyer barn, later known as the Troyer-Fraser barn, was reassembled in Milton, Ontario at what was then the Ministry of Agriculture Museum. The site, now known as Country Heritage Park, proudly displays this other little piece of Fisherville history, and it is easily viewed as you pass in either direction along the 401 highway. (And if you are wondering about the addition of the name Fraser - the Troyer barn and property later came into the possession of prominent men's clothier, Jack Fraser, who used it to house his prize winning cattle.)
Fisherville's other claim to fame is its place in medical history. What is today the massive gated Sanofi Pasteur complex, on the south side of Steeles and just east of Dufferin, was once the site of Jacob Fisher's southern property where he built his saw and grist mills. On a remaining 58-acre portion of the land, which had been subdivided over time, the Connaught Antitoxin Laboratories and University Farm opened in 1917. Named after the Duke of Connaught and run by Dr. John Gerald "Gerry" Fitzgerald, the site housed labs and horse stables. It was here that, using horses as living antitoxin producers, massive amounts of tetanus and meningitis serums were produced. (A little west, running southwest from Steeles, you may take note of the street named Gerry Fitzgerald Drive and recognize its connection to the area.)
In 1923, Connaught Laboratories began a sixty-year run of supplying all of Canada with insulin, which had been pioneered by University of Toronto scientists Dr. Frederick Banting, Charles Best and Dr. James Collip, under lab director Prof. J.J. R. Macleod. With Connaught Labs able to mass produce insulin, the university’s Fisherville site became a leader in biomedical research. The site is also associated with, among others, polio and smallpox vaccines.
In 1972 the University of Toronto sold Connaught Laboratories to the Canadian Development Corporation and it became a for-profit organization that has developed into the current Sanofi Pasteur business, the largest company in the world dedicated only to vaccine production.
And so, while it may seem that Toronto and Vaughan's once rural community of Fisherville is lost, this is far from the truth. From the street and school names, the little pioneer cemetery that is still standing guard over the area, the moved and preserved church visited by museum-goers and wedding celebrants each year to the moved and preserved octagonal barn that is, at a minimum, seen by thousands on the highway each year, Fisherville lives on. And where the branch of the west Don River still flows south through Jacob Fisher’s 1797 land grant, life-saving vaccines that are used around the world are researched and produced daily.
P.S. On our way back to the car from the Fisherville cemetery, I spotted an old survey marker. I'm not sure of the date and despite a stint working at a museum about a provincial land surveyor, I don't know how exactly it is used. But it is another tiny piece of history linking back to a time, not that long ago, when the area was largely undeveloped.