08/29/2026
Carol Speed reached a title role in 1974, but the most revealing object in her story may be a permission clause. The settlement over Abby said the film could not be reissued without Warner Bros.’ approval, complicating the afterlife of one of Speed’s biggest performances. You know how much can disappear when access disappears. Preservation is not the glamorous part of movie history, but it decides who future generations get to meet.
Three years before that clause existed, Carol Speed was in Louisville, Kentucky, preparing to carry a movie.
The production was called Possess My Soul while it was being made. The budget was modest, the schedule was fast, and Speed had received the part with little time to prepare.
She later recalled being told to pick up the script and leave for Louisville within days. Reading it, she thought about The Three Faces of Eve and saw something she had not often been handed by Hollywood.
She called Abby “a wonderful vehicle to show off my acting.”
That sentence tells you what was at stake before the lawyers ever arrived.
Carol Speed was twenty-nine. She had already appeared on television, worked beside Diahann Carroll, played opposite Max Julien in The Mack, shared the screen with Pam Grier in The Big Bird Cage, and built a face audiences could recognize.
Recognition, however, was not the same thing as being trusted with a story.
Again and again, Speed had been asked to make supporting women memorable. She could give a girlfriend watchfulness, an inmate personality, a woman at the edge of a male character’s ambitions enough presence that audiences carried her out of the theater.
Abby put the burden somewhere else.
She was Abby Williams, a marriage counselor and minister’s wife surrounded by a Black family and church community. When a destructive spiritual force overtakes her, the film depends on Speed making audiences believe both in the woman they met and in the terrible change consuming her.
Her face had to hold the movie together.
Her voice did too.
In one church sequence, Speed performed a song she had written herself, “My Soul Is a Witness.” The American Film Institute still credits her as both writer and performer.
That small credit has become one of the most revealing details in the story.
An actress entered somebody else’s production, spoke somebody else’s screenplay, worked under somebody else’s direction, and appeared in a movie somebody else owned. Yet for a few minutes, the voice coming through the film belonged to Carol Speed in another sense too.
She had written what she was singing.
The Louisville shoot also left her with a memory that had nothing to do with demons.
In April 1974, a devastating outbreak of tornadoes struck Louisville and much of the country. Speed later remembered the daytime sky darkening while she and veteran actress Juanita Moore were working on Abby.
The two women left the set.
Speed recalled that they ended up wrapped in blankets on the floor of their hotel lobby because the building had no basement or tornado shelter. The movie was supposed to manufacture terror, but for a time the danger was outside the production entirely.
Then they went back to making the picture.
That image deserves room in Carol Speed’s story.
A twenty-nine-year-old Black actress, suddenly carrying the title role of a feature film, is in Kentucky with Juanita Moore, one of the women who had already spent decades navigating an industry that rarely knew what to do with Black actresses. They are making a low-budget horror movie during a moment when Black films are filling theaters, and neither woman can know what kind of future the work will have.
Hollywood was changing quickly around them.
The early 1970s had opened space that had long been denied. Black detectives, rebels, lovers, hustlers, families, heroes, criminals, professionals, and complicated women were appearing on screens in numbers that would have been difficult to imagine only a few years earlier.
But an opening in the marketplace was not the same thing as institutional security.
Studios and independent producers had learned that Black audiences bought tickets. That discovery created jobs, but it did not automatically create lasting protection for the films, stable careers for the actors, or archives prepared to carry the work forward.
Carol Speed knew the opportunity and the limitation from experience.
Born Carolyn Ann Stewart in Bakersfield in 1945 and raised in San Jose, she had been performing since childhood. At about twelve she appeared in a San Jose Light Opera production of The King and I, and later accounts identify her as the first Black homecoming queen in Santa Clara County.
She trained at the American Conservatory Theater on scholarship and sang backup for Bobbie Gentry at Harrah’s in Reno before television gave her another route in.
There were appearances on Julia, Days of Our Lives, and Sanford and Son. Then came films, including The New Centurions, The Big Bird Cage, and, in 1973, The Mack.
Lulu in The Mack made Speed especially memorable.
But Lulu still lived inside Goldie’s movie. His choices generated the story, and the women around him absorbed many of the consequences.
That was why Abby mattered differently.
Her character had a name large enough to become the title.
The movie opened on Christmas Day, December 25, 1974, in Los Angeles and New York. Speed appeared with William Marshall, Terry Carter, Austin Stoker, and Juanita Moore in a story built largely around Black relationships rather than placing Black characters on the margins of somebody else’s nightmare.
The film was also unmistakably arriving in the wake of The Exorcist.
That was not something invented decades later by horror fans.
A Boxoffice review published two days before Abby opened complained that the similarities reached “down to the camera angles.” The possessed character was now an adult Black woman rather than a white child, and the film pushed its material in a more sexually explicit direction.
Then imitation became a legal question.
In 1975, Warner Bros., which controlled The Exorcist, sued Mid-America Pictures and American International Pictures for copyright infringement. Warner argued that Abby was substantially similar to its blockbuster and that the studio had suffered damages because the competing film had been released.
This is where the story often gets flattened.
Over time, retellings have said Warner Bros. simply won the case, had Abby banned, and wiped the movie from existence.
The surviving trade record says something more complicated.
According to a December 1977 Hollywood Reporter item preserved by the American Film Institute, the case ended in an out-of-court settlement. The payment was undisclosed, and one of the settlement’s conditions said Abby could not be reissued without Warner Bros.’ permission.
There it is.
Permission.
Not a dramatic courtroom verdict. Not a bonfire of film prints. Not a mysterious order making every copy disappear overnight.
A clause.
That is quieter than the legend, but historically it may be more revealing.
Films do not remain alive merely because somebody once finished them.
They have to circulate.
They return to theaters. They move to television. They are licensed for home video. New prints are struck. Negatives are located. Restorations are financed. Festivals program them. Critics reconsider them. Teachers put them on syllabi. A teenager encounters one forty years later and suddenly recognizes an actor everybody else has forgotten.
Availability creates inheritance.
When circulation becomes difficult, memory narrows.
That matters enormously when the performance at the center belongs to a Black woman whose career was still being built.
No surviving document proves that the Abby lawsuit ended Carol Speed’s career. Saying so would make the story cleaner than the evidence allows.
Hollywood careers fracture for countless reasons, and Speed’s own life after the mid-1970s cannot responsibly be reduced to one corporation, one settlement, or one film.
But we do know what she had said about this role.
It was a vehicle to show what she could do.
And we know what eventually happened to that vehicle.
One of the largest performances of her career became unusually difficult for later generations to encounter through ordinary commercial circulation.
That is a particular kind of loss.
A casting director cannot be impressed by a performance that is unavailable. A critic cannot easily reconsider it. A young Black actress cannot stumble across it on television. A generation cannot casually discover what an earlier generation had already seen.
Meanwhile, The Exorcist continued along the path that major studio films are built to travel.
It remained commercially available, repeatedly reissued and discussed, woven deeper into the official story of American horror.
Abby survived differently.
It did not vanish completely. Collectors, horror audiences, unofficial copies, repertory screenings, and later interest helped keep the film from becoming only a title in old advertisements.
But survival and preservation are not synonyms.
A damaged copy existing somewhere is not the same thing as a carefully preserved film being readily available to audiences.
And that distinction becomes sharper when you look again at Carol Speed.
Before Abby, she had spent years entering stories through side doors.
After it, she did not suddenly receive a string of title roles.
She later appeared in Rudy Ray Moore’s Disco Godfather in 1979, but the rapid succession of film work that had defined the first half of the decade did not continue at the same pace. She ultimately stepped away from regular screen acting before returning much later for the 2006 independent film Village Vengeance.
Yet Speed did something worth noticing when the cameras became less reliable keepers of her story.
She wrote.
In 1980, she published Inside Black Hollywood. She later wrote The Georgette Harvey Story and contributed to Gods in Polyester, or a Survivors’ Account of 70s Cinema Obscura.
There is no need to romanticize that turn.
Writing a book does not compensate an actress for roles she might have played. Surviving a difficult industry does not transform its limitations into a blessing.
But it meant that Carol Speed did not leave every version of herself in Hollywood’s custody.
Some of the record came from her.
Carol Speed died in Muskogee, Oklahoma, on January 14, 2022. She was seventy-six.
By then, people could look back at The Mack, Black Samson, The Big Bird Cage, Abby, and the other surviving fragments of her career and see a woman who had been far more than scenery inside 1970s Black cinema.
Still, Abby remains the sharpest contradiction.
The role that gave Speed the title also became attached to a restriction governing whether the title could return.
The actress had done what performers are asked to do. She learned the part, went to Louisville, worked through a production interrupted by real disaster, carried the movie’s emotional and physical demands, and put her own music inside it.
Then control passed somewhere else.
That is why the permission clause matters more than the mythology surrounding the lawsuit.
It reminds us that Black film history can be lost without anyone literally destroying the film. It can disappear by degrees, through neglected elements, complicated ownership, unavailable rights, unmade restorations, inaccessible prints, and decades during which a performance cannot easily reach the people who might have carried it forward.
Carol Speed once looked at Abby and saw a chance to show the world how much she could do.
She did her part.
The unfinished part belongs to the afterlife of the work: whether the films Black artists made are preserved well enough to outlive the moment that briefly made room for them, whether their performances remain accessible enough to challenge the histories written without them, and whether a young person fifty years later can press play and meet Carol Speed not as a forgotten name in somebody else’s movie, but as the woman standing at the center of her own.
I invest a lot of time researching and sharing these important stories. If you’d like to support the work behind them, here’s the link:
https://ko-fi.com/blackhistoryrevealed
Every coffee truly helps.