02/05/2025
We were recently asked about the Mill Village store and post office.
Susan Pappas Babka, the granddaughter of the 1950’s to 1970’s store owners could remember visits to the store, but not its location. This prompted us to go back through time to trace the history of the building. We searched our photo archive, property records, and the list of post masters.
We found two photos from the past. The first, is from when the store was owned by Lorenzo S. Chamberlain between 1891 and 1908. Look at the nice bay storefront window and the long covered porch. Next is a picture of the store and post office when it was The O S Lear store. Orra S. Lear bought the store in 1912 and the Lears owned it until 1920. Notice the porch roof is gone, but the bay window remains.
The grandparents of Susan Pappas Babka were Ernest and Louise Gallatly, who owned the store and operated the post office from 1957 to 1972. At that time it was an IGA grocery, and had a Texaco gas pump out front. Susan Pappas Babka posted the undated picture of her grandparent’s store that we are reposting here. She also posted another view where you can just barely see the big stone chimney that is still in place today. And finally, we see the store today, now very much different, fixed up and housing apartments.
The 1970’s are not long ago. Does anyone have other pictures from that era? Anyone remember the Gallatly’s? If so, please let us know. Susan says they were known as Mr and Mrs G. It is a big jump from our last photo to the building of today.
For more about the early history of the store, anyone can read The History of Goshen by Walter R Nelson. The 1957 edition is available on the Internet Archive here: https://archive.org/details/historyofgoshenn00nels/page/n1/mode/2up. In that edition the store history is on pages 282-286. The updated edition is available at the Goshen Library.